difference between this two urls

[erosmembers]

What is the difference between this two links concerning internal counting:
/scj/cgi/out.php?url=http://domain/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG- ... UMB_LINK-->
and
/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG-->/index.html" rot_id="<!--THUMB_LINK-->"
(with JS to assign rot_id to link)

I know that the second one might be better for google, but I will not lost counting.

[admin]

I don't know which one is better for google but

if you use version 1.*


/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG-->/index.html

will not be counted as it's a rewite to scj/tube/index.php that generates pages only.



/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG-->/index.html" rot_id="<!--THUMB_LINK-->"
if you use JS to add a parameter the final URL will be
/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG-->/index.html?<!--THUMB_LINK-->"

and that's a rewrite to out.php, so you'll get skimming, click will be counted and so on


/scj/cgi/out.php?url=http://domain/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG- ... UMB_LINK-->

so click will be counted + redirected to

http://domain/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG- ... UMB_LINK-->
and most likely counted again

[erosmembers]

/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG-->/index.html" rot_id="<!--THUMB_LINK-->"
if you use JS to add a parameter the final URL will be
/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG-->/index.html?<!--THUMB_LINK-->"
and that's a rewrite to out.php, so you'll get skimming, click will be counted and so on


/scj/cgi/out.php?url=http://domain/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG- ... UMB_LINK-->
so click will be counted + redirected to


your both versions above do the same in case of existing rewrite rule?
So skimming is done in second version too?

[admin]

Yes, but most likely 2 times

[erosmembers]

Sorry, what do you mean?

What is when done two times?

[admin]

If you want to have urls with /scj/cgi/out.php it should be

/scj/cgi/out.php?url=http://domain/gallery/<!--GALLERY_SLUG- ... UMB_LINK-->